Ben & Jack’s Steakhouse is the new kid on the block in Midtown East, serving up some seriously good steak. But with a solid 4.61 out of 5 stars on Resy and a spot in their 'New on Resy' collection, getting a reservation isn’t exactly a walk in Central Park. Here's how to get your name on the list.
How Reservations Work at Ben & Jack's Steakhouse
Ben & Jack’s is all about Resy — that's your first stop for reservations. Slots drop about 30 days in advance. It’s a two-dollar-sign spot, but don’t get it twisted — the steak is top-tier for its price.
Want to dine at peak times like 7 PM on a Saturday? Set your Resy alerts because those tables are snapped up quicker than the bread basket.
What to Order
While we're hyper-focused on getting you in, here’s a quick teaser — the steak is undebatably the star. But don't overlook the sides. Trust the locals’ insider tip: their creamed spinach and mashed potatoes are not to be missed.
The Walk-In Strategy
If you’re feeling spontaneous, walk-ins are possible. Here’s the catch: the bar area is your friend. You might wait a bit, but the atmosphere is lively, and who doesn’t love making friends over a cocktail?
How to Get a Reservation at Ben & Jack's Steakhouse
Here’s a step-by-step on making that reservation happen:
- Download the Resy app. Make sure your notifications are on — this is crucial.
- Watch for new slots. They typically open 30 days in advance. Prime time slots (7-8 PM) go fast.
- Be flexible with party size. Consider a smaller table if you can swing it.
- Check for cancellations. Life happens — people cancel. Resy updates these immediately.
Pro tip: Use Reservation Wrangler to monitor Resy automatically and scoop up tables as they open. It’s the backup you need.
Is It Worth the Hype?
With its central location in Midtown East and glowing reviews, the buzz around Ben & Jack’s is warranted. People are raving about the consistent quality without the gouge-your-wallet prices.
For an authentic NYC steakhouse experience without the jaw-drop prices, it’s a solid bet. Plus, there's the charm of knowing you're in on something relatively new and exciting in the neighborhood.
Getting a table at Ben & Jack’s Steakhouse doesn't have to feel like winning a lottery. With Resy and a little help from Reservation Wrangler, you’ll be slicing into steak before you know it. Just don’t forget to let us know how that mashed potato tasted.