Midtown
Italian
Resy

La Piazza: Snagging a Coveted Reservation in Midtown East

Your insider guide to dining at one of NYC's newest Italian gems


Reservation Wrangler Team

· Updated

La Piazza

Landing a reservation at La Piazza, Midtown East's newest Italian destination, is no easy feat. This spot is making waves on Resy, with a solid 4.2 out of 5 rating and a feature in the 'New on Resy' collection. The allure? Authentic Italian cuisine at a wallet-friendly price tier of just one dollar sign.

So, how do you snag a table at La Piazza when it seems like everyone else wants in?

How Reservations Work at La Piazza

Reservations at La Piazza are managed through Resy. This means you're up against a well-organized system, but with a bit of strategy, you can rise above the crowd.

When to Book

  • Slot Drops: New reservations typically open up 30 days in advance. Aim to book as soon as they drop.
  • Party Size: Be flexible with your party size. Tables for smaller groups might be easier to come by.

Tips for Landing a Table

Getting a reservation at La Piazza doesn't have to feel like winning the lottery. Here’s a step-by-step strategy to improve your odds:

  1. Set a Reminder: Know when reservations open for your preferred date, and set a reminder to be on Resy at that exact time.
  2. Leverage Technology: Use Reservation Wrangler to automatically monitor and grab cancellations or newly opened tables.
  3. Try Different Times: If dinner is booked, aim for lunch. Less popular times might have availability.
  4. Go Solo: Dining alone can sometimes open up more immediate reservation opportunities.
  5. Cancellations: Check Resy often, especially in the 24 hours leading up to your desired time. People cancel, and slots open up last minute.

Pro Tip: Bar seating is often first-come, first-served. If you're in the area, pop in and check for bar availability.

Is It Worth Booking?

Absolutely. For anyone wandering through Midtown East with a craving for Italian, La Piazza delivers. The ambiance, combined with the pricing, makes it a rare find in a city where dining can burn a hole through your wallet faster than a taxi to JFK.

The Walk-In Strategy

If you find yourself without a reservation, don't lose hope. Consider these walk-in strategies:

  • Arrive early, preferably right when they open. This gives you the best shot at nabbing a bar seat or one of the no-show tables.
  • Call ahead to check for any current availability. Sometimes a bit of charm and politeness can work wonders.

In the constant hustle for NYC's hottest tables, having a tool like Reservation Wrangler in your arsenal can make all the difference. Automatically monitor reservations and grab that table at La Piazza the moment it opens up. Enjoy your meal!

You can start your journey by checking out La Piazza on Resy.

Get booked when a table opens up

Reservation Wrangler watches Resy, OpenTable, and DoorDash for the dates and party size you pick, then books the slot the moment it appears. 7-day free trial.