Japanese
new openings
Omakase 95
NYC Dining
Japanese Cuisine
Upper West Side
New York

Landing a Reservation at Omakase 95: Your Upper West Side Sushi Spot

Why this new Upper West Side sushi bar is worth the hype and how to secure your table


R

Reservation Wrangler Team

August 17, 2026
Omakase 95

Omakase 95 isn't just another sushi spot on the Upper West Side. It's the new darling of the Resy scene, boasting a stellar 4.9242 rating. But let's face it — getting a reservation is like trying to win the NYC apartment lottery.


How Reservations Work at Omakase 95

Omakase 95 operates exclusively through Resy. They’re new on the block, but their seats vanish faster than you can say "sashimi." Here's how to game the system.

When to Book

Slots drop at midnight, and you’re looking at a race against the clock. Trust me, you want to be there at 11:59 PM, finger poised on your keyboard like a Supreme sale. Weekends fill up first, so target those midweek slots if your schedule allows.

Party-Size Strategy

The place is cozy, and they favor smaller groups. Parties of two have the best shot. Forget about bringing your entire book club — you’ll be splitting up if you want in.

Leverage Cancellations and Waitlists

Cancellations happen. Check again at around 9 AM and 3 PM, when plans tend to fall apart and spots open up. Sign up for the Resy Notify function for Omakase 95 on their Resy page. You might just get lucky.

Pro tip: Use Reservation Wrangler to automatically monitor and snag a reservation the moment one becomes available.


The Walk-In Strategy

Rolling in without a reservation? Brave. But not impossible.

Timing is Everything

Arrive right when they open or late in the evening. Chance a bar seat; it's your best bet. Staff are more likely to accommodate singles and duos who can squeeze into those precious spots. Don't wait for a text-back from your friend — be ready to go solo.


Is It Worth the Hype?

Omakase 95 serves an authentic, yet affordable omakase experience on the Upper West Side, a rare find considering the typical price points downtown. Traditional, straightforward, and a hit on the taste buds, it belongs in your dining diary.

With its Resy rating of 4.9242, it’s giving those pricier competitors a run for their yen. If you're a sushi aficionado or simply tired of the same old rolls, this spot delivers.


What to Expect

A sushi bar with intimate vibes, nested in a neighborhood that usually shies away from such culinary adventures. The space is charming, focusing on quality rather than frills. Expect to savor sushi sliced with precision and passion.

For a sneak peek, check out their Instagram for latest menu shots and updates.


Final Thought: Don't leave your Omakase 95 reservations to chance. Use Reservation Wrangler to monitor and seize that elusive table. Consider their signup page your new best friend.


Ready to snag that reservation?Let Reservation Wrangler monitor and book your perfect table automatically.
Book a Table at Omakase 95: Insider Tips | Reservation Wrangler